Sun Tzu and price wars: revenue, margin and wear and tear

Selling more after a price cut does not prove that the company is achieving a better result. To assess the change, you need to relate price, costs, units sold and duration. Sun Tzu's warning about wear and tear helps frame that question; it does not decide a rate.

The relationship between price wars and Sun Tzu is an analogy about the cost of prolonging a confrontation. Within Sun Tzu in marketing and negotiation, it is worth checking what remains after sustaining a price reduction. Not every price cut destroys value, and this educational analysis does not recommend a financial policy for a specific company.

A one-off promotion is not the same as a price war

Chapter 2 of Lionel Giles's version links the length of war with the depletion of resources. The cost of war in chapter 2 develops that argument. Applying it to price is a contemporary comparison, not a commercial rule from the treatise.

For this explanation, a price war is a dynamic of successive price cuts in response to other sellers. A one-off promotion, by contrast, may have a pre-defined scope and duration. The distinction depends on how the action is decided and assessed; calling it a promotion does not remove its costs.

The question is what would have to change for the lower revenue per unit to be offset. It may be possible to sell more, alter the cost of providing the service, or change the mix of what is sold. None of those effects should be assumed as certain before they are checked.

Nor do we know the competitor's cost structure by looking at its price list. Copying its reduction does not show that we can sustain it under the same conditions. The example below keeps several elements constant precisely to show what changes when only price and volume vary.

Numerical example: more sales, but a worse result

Suppose a fictional company sells a single product for 100 euros, with a total variable cost of 60 euros per unit and monthly fixed costs of 3,000 euros. Initially, it sells 100 units a month. Taxes and financing costs are excluded, and it is assumed that available capacity allows the compared volumes to be handled without increasing fixed costs.

The contribution margin is the difference between revenue and variable costs. That amount helps cover fixed costs; what remains afterwards is the simplified operating result in this example. It should not be confused with net profit or with cash already collected.

Initial situation: 100 units at 100 euros

Monthly revenue is 100 × 100 = 10,000 euros. Variable costs total 100 × 60 = 6,000 euros. That leaves 4,000 euros of contribution and, after subtracting the 3,000 euros of fixed costs, an operating result of 1,000 euros.

Each unit contributes 40 euros before fixed costs are covered. That figure describes the structure chosen for the exercise. It does not establish what margin another product needs or how much a real company should charge.

Cut to 90 euros and increase to 120 units

Now imagine a 10% reduction in price and a 20% increase in units sold. The volume of 120 units is an assumption, not a demand forecast. At that price, each sale contributes 90 − 60 = 30 euros.

Revenue rises to 120 × 90 = 10,800 euros and variable costs to 120 × 60 = 7,200 euros. Contribution stands at 3,600 euros. After deducting the same fixed costs, the operating result is 600 euros.

Turnover has increased by 800 euros, but the result has fallen from 1,000 to 600 euros: a 40% drop. The difference arises because the increase in units does not fully offset the lower contribution from each sale. If volume had remained at 100 units, the result would have been zero.

How much volume would be needed to recover the original result

To reach 1,000 euros again after covering 3,000 euros of fixed costs, 4,000 euros of contribution would be needed. At 30 euros per unit, the calculation is 4,000 ÷ 30 ≈ 133.33. As the product is sold in whole units, at least 134 units would be required, giving a result of 1,020 euros.

That threshold is only valid under the stated assumptions. If handling more orders requires expanding facilities, hiring additional support or taking on another variable cost, the calculation has to be redone. The formula does not prove that there are enough buyers or that the team can deliver that volume.

What changes when the discount is maintained

Duration allows another effect to be observed. If the 1,000-euro and 600-euro result scenarios were repeated over six months respectively, the accumulated difference would be 2,400 euros. This is a hypothetical comparison with constant conditions, not a prediction of what will happen after a price is lowered.

A short promotion would also need to examine what sales would have occurred without it. If some buyers merely bring forward an order they intended to place later, counting all promotional activity as additional demand would exaggerate the effect. To analyse that possibility, it is necessary to observe a period that includes what happens when the offer ends.

There are situations the example does not cover: products with different costs, stock that it makes sense to clear, real changes in fulfilment, or complementary sales. Their existence prevents us from saying that every discount is harmful. Each interpretation needs to incorporate the effects it seeks to use to justify it.

The search for market niches raises another question: what need is being met and what difference does the buyer recognise? Negotiation with a dignified exit looks at how to adjust terms and scope. None of those routes guarantees that a price reduction can be replaced by a sufficient improvement.

The answer is also not to agree prices with competitors. This explanation is limited to examining independent decisions based on a company's own costs, capacity and trading conditions. It does not propose price coordination or assume that all market participants suffer the same consequences.

If the company is struggling to meet its obligations, the calculation does not determine its viability. Reading Sun Tzu in a business crisis sets the limits of that metaphor. A specific financial decision requires reviewing the actual documentation with professionals, rather than turning the example into an instruction to raise or lower prices.

When reviewing a price cut, separate units sold, contribution and result, and specify the period over which they are compared. An increase in revenue alone is not enough to close the assessment.

View all articles in Sun Tzu in marketing: positioning, sales and negotiation