Attacking the enemy's strategy: acting on their plans

A plan can stop working even if the person who designed it still has their resources. Attacking strategy means acting on the relationship between what the adversary wants to achieve, the conditions they need, and the means they expect to use to do so.

Attacking the enemy's strategy directs attention to their plans rather than to the clash between forces. Within the guide to understanding winning without fighting, this idea raises a specific question: what would have to change so that the adversary could no longer obtain the result they expect through their plan?

The plan is the object of attack

Griffith places the attack on strategy in chapter 3, section 4; Giles speaks of frustrating plans in section 3. The position of the wording expresses a priority of the treatise. It does not establish that every campaign must follow an identical sequence, nor does it guarantee that a discovered plan can be neutralised.

To interpret that priority, it is worth distinguishing aim, plan, and action. The aim is the sought-after result. The plan links means and conditions in order to achieve it. An action is one part of its execution. Interrupting a visible activity does not necessarily mean the relationship sustaining the whole has been altered.

For example, delaying a decision may be irrelevant if the adversary has time and alternatives. By contrast, if a necessary condition ceases to be met, they may be forced to rethink their entire approach. The difference lies in the function of that condition, not in how dramatic the event is.

“Attacking” should be read here as acting against the viability of the plan, without reducing the expression to a verbal dispute about its merits. Refuting an argument before an audience and causing a strategy to become impracticable are different outcomes. A criticism may be correct and yet not change what the adversary can do.

This distinction connects with the meaning of supreme military excellence. The interest lies in achieving a result that does not depend on first destroying all of the opposing side's capability. But disrupting a plan is not the same as resolving the confrontation once and for all: another plan or a different objective may emerge.

Information allows intentions and assumptions to be examined

Chapter 13 links advance knowledge of the adversary with information from people. The study of the five kinds of spy in chapter 13 develops that context. What matters here is one consequence: understanding a plan requires data, as well as a convincing explanation of how it might work.

Capabilities indicate which actions are possible; intentions indicate which are intended to be carried out. They are not interchangeable. Having a resource does not prove it will be used, and announcing an intention does not prove there are sufficient means to fulfil it. A precise interpretation keeps those statements separate.

It is also worth distinguishing a confirmed intention from an inference. A report may describe observed preparations without knowing their purpose. From them it is possible to form hypotheses, but presenting them as if they were verified orders adds a certainty that observation does not contain.

Assumptions are the conditions the plan takes for granted as available: cooperation, enough time, or an expected response. To analyse them, one must ask which are necessary and which merely facilitate execution. If a condition can be replaced, its disappearance may create difficulty without invalidating the plan.

External support illustrates that problem. Its role is examined in the role of alliances in Sun Tzu. Knowing that a relationship exists is not enough: what matters is what commitment it sustains and for which part of the project it is relevant. The existence of contacts does not prove an unlimited willingness to cooperate.

Information loses its usefulness when it is used solely to confirm a prior explanation. If a piece of data fits several hypotheses, choosing the most convenient one does not eliminate the others. It is worth keeping track of the doubts that could change the interpretation, especially when it is unknown whether the plan remains in force.

A hypothetical example of a plan that loses its main condition

Imagine a fictional negotiation between an organisation and a supplier. The supplier aims to secure acceptance of certain conditions because it assumes the service must begin immediately and that there is no alternative compatible with that timetable. The example is a contemporary analogy, not an episode attributed to Sun Tzu.

The organisation discovers that part of the service can be delayed and that a temporary solution covers the immediate need. It has not removed the supplier's capability or shown that their product is defective. It has changed the urgency condition on which that way of negotiating depended.

The analysis requires checking that the temporary solution truly meets the need. If it only seems sufficient and then fails, the supposed alternative would not have changed the problem. The distinction between an imagined possibility and a viable option is what allows the example to be assessed.

Nor do the differences between the parties automatically disappear. The supplier may maintain their conditions, offer others, or withdraw. What ceases to hold is a specific expectation: that urgency will force acceptance. The result is a change in the options available, not control over the other party's will.

This analogy shows why acting on plans is not the same as psychological warfare in general. It does not require provoking fear, humiliating someone, or spreading a falsehood. The focus falls on an identifiable dependency and on checking whether it still exists.

In the business sphere, competitive intelligence using open sources allows this relationship between information and interpretation to be studied through public materials. It is a different adaptation of the military espionage described in the treatise. The example does not require access to private communications or obtaining secrets from former employees.

To assess a similar situation, the crucial question is what evidence would show that the initial assumption has ceased to hold. Without that check, an elegant explanation may have been built while the opposing plan remains perfectly viable.

When analysing a plan, distinguish the desired result from the conditions needed to achieve it. Indicate what you know, what you infer, and what change would force you to revise your interpretation.

View all articles in Winning without fighting: meaning, approaches and limits in Sun Tzu