Treating employees as ‘beloved children’ is not a literal model of employment. The image in the treatise lets us ask how care and coordination coexist, but a business adaptation must recognise people’s autonomy and make expectations explicit.
Applying Sun Tzu to human resources requires distinguishing care for the team from demanding personal loyalty. Within Sun Tzu applied to leadership, the question is how to organise support, responsibilities and follow-up without infantilising those who work or promising that one practice will be enough to retain them.
What ‘beloved children’ means within the treatise
The image appears in chapter 10, section 25 of Lionel Giles’s English translation. The text compares caring for soldiers with caring for one’s own children and links it to accompanying the general even to death. ‘Beloved children’ refers here to that image; no specific Spanish edition is being quoted.
Section 26 adds a warning: affection does not solve an inability to enforce instructions and command the army. The commentary on the six terrains of chapter 10 places these passages alongside the responsibilities of command. The relationship described remains military.
A workplace adaptation must change that framework explicitly. Employees are adults with their own judgement; receiving support should not create a debt of personal obedience. Nor should a disagreement be read as ingratitude, or leaving the company as a family betrayal.
What is useful in the comparison is a management question: how do you care for people while also making shared work understandable? The answer proposed here uses expectations, resources and review of agreements. It does not transfer the ancient passage’s demands for sacrifice into the workplace.
Caring, clarifying expectations and applying fair criteria
Care can start by checking what is actually being asked for. A task needs a recognisable outcome, available resources and a deadline that can be discussed if conditions change. Phrases like ‘take ownership’ or ‘show a better attitude’ do not clarify what is missing or how to know whether it has been resolved.
Attention to physical and mental wellbeing should not be limited to asking whether everything is alright. In this approach, the manager reviews workloads, interruptions and opportunities to rest, and addresses difficulties that are raised. They do not need to diagnose anyone or demand intimate explanations in order to listen to an organisational problem.
Support should match the difficulty observed. What may be missing is an explanation, a tool, access to information or time free from interruptions. Before attributing an error to indifference, it is worth checking those conditions. Listening to a person’s explanation does not mean accepting any conclusion, but it does avoid deciding before hearing their version.
Here, discipline is understood as coordination through clear agreements. An incident should have an owner; an unfinished task should not be recorded as complete. When something goes wrong, the fact is reviewed and a correction is agreed. There is no need to turn that review into a global judgement of the person or a public humiliation.
Fair treatment also does not require identical responses to different circumstances. Someone who is learning may need support that another person no longer needs. Consistency lies in explaining the criterion applied and checking whether it fits the work, without reserving exceptions for those who are closer to management.
The five virtues of the business leader allow this approach to be linked to the decisions of the person in charge. Benevolence does not replace clarity, and discipline does not justify arbitrary harshness. Both should be visible in what the manager does, including when their own actions contributed to the problem.
Agreed follow-up leaves room to do the work. The analysis of how to avoid micromanaging staff distinguishes reviewing results from replacing every decision. Asking for autonomy while requiring permission for every step creates contradictory expectations, even if it is presented as a way of helping.
An example of correction without punishment or humiliation
Imagine a fictional support team. A professional has sent several incomplete replies to customer queries. Their manager reviews the cases and arranges a private conversation. The starting point is the specific replies and the missing information, not the claim that the person lacks commitment.
When they review the process together, they discover that there are two different sets of instructions and that some queries require a technical confirmation that is difficult to obtain. In addition, the professional deals with interruptions that are not included in the plan. These facts do not remove the need to correct the replies; they clarify what needs to change in order to do so.
In the example, they agree on a single current instruction, identify who will resolve the technical question and set aside time to review the first cases. The manager removes a secondary task rather than adding training on top of an unchanged workload. The professional undertakes to flag queries that cannot be completed with the information available.
The expectation is made explicit: a query is not closed while the data needed to answer it is still missing. If it depends on someone else, that blockage is logged. In this way, unfinished work is distinguished from non-compliance, and the only way to appear to make progress is not to close incomplete cases.
The later review uses a sample of replies to check whether the criterion has been understood and whether difficulties continue. It does not publicly rank people or assume that no complaints equals good work. It also checks whether the instruction is still ambiguous and whether the promised support was available.
If the problem continues, it is necessary to examine which part of the agreement is not working, rather than repeating the same warning more harshly. The risks of deciding with anger and ego help distinguish the discomfort of the manager from the reasons for a management decision.
The case describes a way of reviewing work, not a guaranteed result. Even if the replies improve, that does not prove the professional will stay with the company. The decision to continue may depend on matters this intervention does not address, and it must be possible to express that without turning the support received into an obligation to remain.
To assess the practice, it is worth asking what changed in the conditions, which expectations were made clear and which difficulties remain open. Team continuity is a broader question. It is not proven by an anecdote, nor is it explained solely by the kindness of the person in charge.
Before asking for more commitment, check whether the expected result is understood and whether there are means to achieve it. Care also means correcting organisational decisions, without treating employees as personal dependants.
View all articles in Leadership with Sun Tzu: how to review a team’s direction
