The five virtues of Sun Tzu applied to the chief executive

The commander’s virtues can become questions about how a person leads: what they check before deciding, how they communicate what they know, and what they expect of the team. The comparison is useful when it is expressed in behaviours, not labels about character.

Applying Sun Tzu to the work of a CEO requires distinguishing the commander’s qualities from the responsibilities of business leadership. The guide to Sun Tzu applied to leadership organises that adaptation. Here, the five virtues are used to examine observable decisions, without presenting them as a formula for success.

What chapter 1 says about the virtues of command

In chapter 1, section 9, of Lionel Giles’s English translation, command is linked to wisdom, sincerity, benevolence, courage and rigour. Giles uses strictness for the final quality. Speaking here of management discipline is an adaptation of that rigour, not a literal quotation from a Spanish edition.

These qualities are not the five factors of chapter 1. Command is one of those factors; the virtues describe the person who exercises it. Confusing the two lists would mix the attributes of the person in charge with broader conditions of military assessment.

The business proposal is to ask what someone does when they need to decide, communicate or correct. Recognising a quality in the abstract is of little use if it cannot be linked to a specific action. The following questions do not score personalities or replace an assessment of the work done.

Five virtues turned into observable behaviours

Wisdom: distinguishing information from assumptions

As an adaptation, wisdom can be observed when the chief executive identifies what they know before committing the team. For example, they compare a sales forecast with delivery capacity and ask what assumption supports the promised date. They do not need to solve every technical detail personally, but they do need to understand what depends on information that is still uncertain.

The tension lies between continuing to investigate and deciding with incomplete knowledge. Requesting another report may clarify a doubt or delay an uncomfortable decision. A useful review identifies which data is missing and how it would change the options. Self-assessment question: what evidence would make me reconsider the decision I am defending?

Sincerity: communicating the real state of the work

One observable behaviour would be to distinguish a target from a confirmed forecast. In a hypothetical launch, saying that you are trying to meet a date does not mean that all dependencies have already been resolved. Sincerity also requires correcting a previous communication when it no longer describes what the team can deliver.

Its tension is not about choosing between lying or telling everything. There may be information that needs to remain confidential; that reserve does not require inventing certainties. It is possible to explain what can be confirmed and what cannot. The question is concrete: am I describing the situation, or trying to make others perceive less uncertainty than actually exists?

Benevolence: attending to the conditions in which people work

Benevolence can be translated into checking workload before accepting a new priority. If one person receives two incompatible assignments, the person in charge decides which one is delayed and takes responsibility for communicating it. Asking for effort without resolving that incompatibility leaves the problem intact. The development of care and discipline in talent management addresses that relationship between support and expectations.

The tension is between attending to an individual need and distributing work in a sustainable way for the whole team. Helping someone should not mean silently shifting their burden to someone else. Self-assessment question: what working condition have I changed after hearing a difficulty, and who is now bearing its cost?

Courage: making decisions that may be uncomfortable

As a business behaviour, courage can consist of stopping an initiative you yourself promoted when its assumptions no longer hold. The decision needs reasons and an explanation of its consequences. Continuing solely to avoid admitting error does not show a greater willingness to take responsibility.

The tension lies between acting under uncertainty and exposing yourself to unnecessary risk in order to demonstrate determination. There may also be decisions that cannot wait until you know everything. Before acting, it is worth asking: am I protecting a justified objective, or defending my reputation through a gamble that others will have to carry out?

Discipline: applying clear criteria, including to the person in charge

Rigour adapted to management can be seen in working agreements that are either kept or explicitly reviewed. If a deliverable needs checking, the chief executive does not remove it without explanation when they are in a hurry. An exception must identify what changes and who takes responsibility for the decision; otherwise, the rule depends on the position of the person requesting it.

The tension appears when a procedure no longer serves the work. Keeping it out of habit is not the same as demanding rigour. Nor is arbitrarily punishing a deviation without checking its causes. Self-assessment question: were the expectations understandable, were the means available, and have I applied the same criterion when reviewing my own contribution?

Contrasting the virtues with the risks in chapter 8

Chapter 8, section 12, lists dangers of command: rashness, cowardice, impetuous temperament, sensitivity to dishonour and excessive concern for the troops, according to Giles. The analysis of the flexibility of command in chapter 8 helps to put them into context. They are not clinical diagnoses or five exact opposites of the virtues above.

The comparison forces us to examine how each quality is exercised. Courage does not make every risk reasonable; discipline does not turn every order into good guidance. A supposed wisdom that ends up demanding personal approval for every detail also deserves review. How to avoid managerial micromanagement develops that boundary between understanding the work and replacing the people who do it.

To use these questions, choose a recent decision and reconstruct what information was available, what was communicated and what happened next. Look for a verifiable change in behaviour, not a statement that you are a wise or courageous leader. An isolated favourable outcome also does not prove that the criterion used was appropriate.

Review a specific decision before judging a virtue. The question is which behaviour you would keep, which you would correct, and what evidence allows you to distinguish the two.

View all articles in Leadership with Sun Tzu: how to review a team’s direction