An unexpected advertising action needs to connect with a clear offer. The combination of Zheng and Qi helps us think about that relationship: what sustains the usual communication, and what complementary intervention can open a different conversation with the audience.
Applying Sun Tzu to guerrilla marketing here means combining continuity and surprise, not turning the customer into an adversary. Within Sun Tzu in marketing and negotiation, this adaptation focuses on how to relate a striking action to the commercial work that makes it possible to respond to the interest generated.
Zheng and Qi describe functions, not fixed channel categories
In chapter 5 of Lionel Giles's translation, direct and indirect methods are combined and transformed into each other. The commentary on Shi, Zheng and Qi in chapter 5 develops that military relationship. Its use in advertising is a contemporary interpretation.
In this analogy, Zheng helps us think about recognisable, ongoing presence: explaining the offer, making contact easier, and maintaining a coherent experience. Qi helps us think about a complementary intervention that changes the usual way of presenting that offer. Neither one on its own identifies a communication medium.
A social media post can be entirely routine; a printed card can be unexpected because of its content or its use. The criterion is what function the action serves in a specific situation. Classifying all traditional advertising as Zheng and all digital action as Qi would erase that difference.
Nor is it necessary to abandon what works in order to introduce a variation. Before designing one, it is worth being clear about what needs to change: getting enquiries about an unfamiliar service, explaining a buying difficulty, or showing a capability that is barely noticed. Surprising the competition does not replace any of those objectives.
A fictional case: a workshop that shows how it repairs backpacks
Imagine a backpack repair workshop. It keeps a page with the jobs it accepts, photos of repairs, and a way to request a quote. It also hands out information cards in its own premises. That set-up constitutes its stable communication; the example does not assume that it produces a particular number of customers.
The workshop wants to test whether it can generate enquiries about tears that some people consider beyond repair. It does not aim to convince people that any backpack can be fixed. It needs the person enquiring to describe the damage and understand that viability depends on the material, the parts available, and the work required.
The complementary action consists of preparing a window display with examples of the process: an open seam, the reinforcement used, and the finished item. The examples are labelled as demonstrations. A short recording of the work makes it possible to share the same explanation without turning it into a promise of results for any object.
The surprise comes from making visible a repair that normally stays behind the counter. The window display leads to the stable information: what can be assessed, how to request a quote, and what the service does not include. The action would lose its point if it drew attention but left those questions unanswered.
To define the audience, the workshop distinguishes between someone who needs a backpack repaired and someone who wants to learn sewing. Both people may be interested in the demonstration, although only the first fits the chosen commercial objective. The search for market niches explains how to connect need and segment without confusing attention with demand.
The case assigns one day to preparing the samples and a two-week trial period. These are fictional limits for the exercise, not recommended timeframes for any business. It also reserves capacity to respond to enquiries: spending all the time on the window display and neglecting requests would make it impossible to assess the proposal as a whole.
The workshop does not invent testimonials or present an exceptional repair as if it were routine. Nor does it advertise nonexistent places or discounts to create urgency. It can show interesting work while keeping its conditions clear. The combination of continuity and surprise does not require deceiving anyone who might hire it.
How to evaluate the campaign without confusing reach and result
Before starting, the workshop defines what it will count as a relevant enquiry: a request about an item and damage that it can assess. It then distinguishes between enquiries received, quotes sent, and jobs accepted. These stages describe different forms of progress; adding them up as if they were all sales would make it impossible to know where the process breaks down.
The views on the recording answer a different question. They show the recorded reach, but they do not prove that those who watched it need a repair. If the action gets attention without relevant enquiries, the audience, the explanation of the offer, or the objective should be reviewed, rather than declaring success on reach alone.
Comparing the two weeks with an earlier period provides a reference point, not definitive proof of causality. In the example, other changes could coincide, such as different opening hours or recommendations from previous customers. Asking how they heard about the workshop helps interpret the requests, even if some people have seen more than one communication piece.
The assessment includes preparation time, responses, and the materials used. Securing additional orders may require more work than expected. That relationship between activity and resources connects with the strain of price wars, although here the aim is not to cut prices to make up for a poorly defined campaign.
The example may end with a demonstration worth repeating, with changes to the usual information, or with the decision not to continue. It does not require virality. A small action can answer the question posed without reaching mass visibility, and mass visibility may not solve it.
The concentration of resources is also examined in startup strategy against a giant. For this workshop, the unresolved decision is more concrete: to check whether the demonstration generates enquiries it can handle, and whether that contribution justifies keeping it. Repeating it automatically just because it was original would leave that evaluation undone.
Before preparing an unexpected action, write down what the interested person should do next and how you will deal with them. That connection makes it possible to assess the campaign beyond its visibility.
View all articles in Sun Tzu in marketing: positioning, sales and negotiation
