Know yourself: self-knowledge and information in Sun Tzu

Know yourself: self-knowledge and information in Sun Tzu

Knowing oneself and knowing the adversary are related tasks, but neither replaces the other. This guide links the assessment of capabilities, information gaps and prudent command. It includes a reading framework for separating what is confirmed, what is assumed and what is still unknown.

What we know about ourselves and what we know about the adversary

Self-knowledge: assessing capabilities and limits

Knowing one’s own assets requires distinguishing between their existence and their availability for a specific task. An inventory may show what resources are held without explaining whether they are ready, how long they can be used, or what conditions limit their use.

The analysis of knowing the enemy and knowing oneself examines the scenarios in the final passage of chapter 3 of The Art of War. The reference to numerous battles belongs to the formulation of the argument; it should not be turned into a percentage of success or a mathematical guarantee.

Self-knowledge is not the same as having a lot or a little confidence in one’s own prospects. The question is which claims about those prospects can be supported and which need to be checked.

The limit of knowing only one’s own situation

Having internal information does not allow one to deduce automatically the adversary’s capabilities or intentions. An assessment may describe one’s own resources accurately and still be insufficient to decide how to use them against another force.

The guide on the risk of ignoring the enemy focuses on that gap. The distinction is practical: knowing what can be done does not yet answer what can be expected from the other side, or how that response would alter the original plan.

A matrix of the known, the assumed and the unknown

As a reading exercise, several areas can be cross-referenced with three information states. The following framework is a proposal for organising the analysis, not a literal classification by Sun Tzu. The examples are hypothetical.

  • Own assets. We know what equipment appears in the inventory. We assume it remains available. We do not know whether its condition has been checked for the intended task.
  • Adversary. We know what activity has been observed. We assume what intention might explain it. We do not know whether there are other means or purposes that have not been identified.
  • Environment. We know what conditions were recorded in a previous reconnaissance. We assume they are still in force. We do not know what changes have occurred since then.

The value of the framework lies in preventing an assumption from changing category simply because it is repeated. An observation may be correct while the explanation built from it is mistaken. Information that was valid before may also need updating.

The assessment of the five factors in chapter 1 offers another route for ordering the questions above. The two exercises can be related without presenting them as a single list from the treatise.

Gathering information and reviewing command judgement

Where the claims come from

Before using a piece of data, it is worth recognising where it comes from and how far it reaches. A report on one part of the situation does not necessarily describe the whole. Likewise, having more messages does not resolve a contradiction if they all depend on the same unchecked information.

The study of the five kinds of spies in chapter 13 addresses information gathering in the book’s military context. It makes it possible to distinguish that task from the subsequent interpretation carried out by command.

Anger, reputation and decisions

Chapter 8 examines the commander’s vulnerabilities, and the closing section of chapter 12 warns against acting in anger. Reading them together makes it possible to separate the emotion of the moment, the decision taken, and consequences that may continue after that emotion has changed.

The analysis of the risks of deciding in anger and ego develops those passages. Its purpose is to study command judgement, not to diagnose personalities or turn the treatise into a method for eliminating emotions.

One review question is to check whether the reasons for a decision would still be sufficient without the urgency of responding to a provocation or defending a reputation. This question belongs to interpretive work and does not replace the evaluation of facts.

Sun Tzu’s strategic philosophy connects this analysis with other decisions in the treatise. As you continue reading, keep the distinction between having information, interpreting it and acting on it.