Giles and Griffith: how to choose a translation of Sun Tzu

Choosing a translation requires looking beyond the name on the cover. The treatment of terms, notes and editorial interventions makes it possible to compare Giles and Griffith according to how the book will be used.

Finding the best translation of Sun Tzu requires being clear about why it will be read.the guide to manuscripts and translations of Sun Tzu

sets out the different versions; here, specific decisions by Lionel Giles and Samuel B. Griffith are compared.

The text and the explanations that accompany it

In Giles, the notes present interpretations by Chinese commentators and explain translation choices. The reader can follow a passage and then examine why it allows a particular reading. This apparatus is especially useful when a Chinese word allows several interpretations.

Griffith's edition includes a historical introduction, commentary, appendices, a bibliography and an index, as well as other editorial material. Those components make it possible to distinguish the study that accompanies the treatise from the translated chapters.

This difference in organisation should be assessed according to the task. To follow an argument without interruptions, it matters to be able to recognise where the main text continues. To study a word, it matters to find the translator's explanation and to know whether alternatives are considered. Ease of reading and the ability to check an interpretation are not the same criterion.

Nor is it enough to set up a contrast between 'philologist' and 'military man' as if they were mutually exclusive categories. A useful comparison asks what reasoning each note offers, what problem it tries to solve and how much the reader can verify. The vocabulary of a translation may sound more technical without that alone guaranteeing greater accuracy with respect to the original.

Three decisions that make it possible to compare the versions

The title of the first chapter: planning or assessing

Giles usesLaying Planswhile Griffith usesEstimates. The two choices guide the reader's first impression of the chapter in different ways.

As a reading guide, 'laying plans' suggests thinking about what will be done, while 'estimates' directs attention to the conditions that must be examined beforehand. This difference in emphasis does not establish an absolute opposition: assessing can be part of planning. What is useful is to check how the title fits the development of the chapter, rather than deciding from the isolated impression of a single word.

Dao: moral law or moral influence

For one of the opening factors, Giles usesMoral Lawwhile Griffith opts for a formulation related to moral influence.

The Spanish glosses 'moral law' and 'moral influence' suggest somewhat different questions. The first may suggest a principle; the second, the effect of conduct on other people. It is a comparison of the emphasis of the expressions, not an assertion that the Chinese term has two completely separate meanings.

To assess the passage, its later explanation must also be read: the relationship between those who lead and those who follow them. Translating an isolated word can hide what the next sentence clarifies. That is why it is worth comparing complete units of meaning rather than building a classification of translations from a dictionary of loose equivalents.

Fa: method and discipline or doctrine

In the fifth factor, Giles usesMethod and disciplinewhile Griffith choosesdoctrine. The difference shows how the same concept can be presented through a descriptive expression or through a more condensed term.

'Method and discipline' breaks the concept into two relatively common words. 'Doctrine' condenses it into a category that the reader must understand within the military context. The second formulation should not automatically be taken as a religious belief; nor does the first authorise reducing the passage to individual obedience.

Editorial interventions also matter. Griffith notes at certain points in his edition that he has reorganised material or made decisions about the arrangement of the text. When an edition makes this kind of intervention, the comparison cannot be limited to finding the same paragraph number.

If two editions do not present exactly the same order, the content must be located and the notes that explain the change read. A translation can make debatable choices and, at the same time, give the reader enough information to recognise and examine them.

How to choose an edition according to use

For a study focused on language problems, it is advisable to consult Giles's annotated edition and work through each passage together with its notes. For a reading that includes extensive historical and military presentation, Griffith's organisation offers that route. These guidelines refer to the components of each edition, not to any universal superiority of one translation over the other.

A beginner can carry out a simple test: read the same passage in both, explain in their own words what they understand, and then review the notes. The doubts that survive that second reading matter more than the first impression of fluency. An apparently transparent text may have quietly resolved an ambiguity that is worth knowing about.

Translation and critical apparatus must also be distinguished. Two editions may offer similar formulations of the text and yet provide very different experiences because one includes extensive notes and another removes almost all commentary. If the aim is to investigate a specific expression, the notes may be as relevant as the fluency of the translation.

In Spanish, the check should begin with the credits. It is necessary to identify who produced the Spanish version, which text it is based on, and whether it preserves introductions and commentary. The name of Giles or Griffith on the cover is not enough to attribute a Castilian sentence to them literally. Nor should it be assumed that a reprint retains all the materials of the original edition.

This point is especially important when a Spanish edition says it is based on an English translation. There may be a second translation decision between English and Spanish. A Castilian word should not be attributed directly to Sun Tzu, Giles or Griffith without checking who actually chose it.

Historical comparison can be extended withAmiot's translation; the shift in interpretive frame, withThomas Cleary's interpretation. It is worth keeping these questions separate: reception history, choice of words and philosophical reading are not interchangeable criteria.

The original editions compared here predate the discovery ofthe Yinqueshan bamboo manuscripts in 1972. Studying those materials requires later documentation; a recent date on the cover of a reprint does not prove that its contents have been updated.

That is why choosing between Giles and Griffith depends on what one wants to verify. Readers interested in comparing vocabulary can work with parallel passages and notes. Those looking for historical context can also pay attention to introductions and appendices. In both cases, identifying the translator's interventions avoids confusing an editorial interpretation with an inevitable equivalent of the Chinese text.

Before choosing an edition, review a sample that includes text and notes. Check the translation credits and what material is preserved; the number of pages alone does not answer those questions.

View all articles in Sun Tzu Translations: Manuscripts, Versions and Reading Criteria